Rascal Flatt’s “Why?” documents indescribable pain and grief felt by a family after losing a loved one to suicide. The lyrics “Why, that’s what I keep asking. Was there anything I could have said or done. Oh why, I had no clue what you were masking. A troubled soul, God only knows what went wrong,” accurately capture the anguish, confusion, and regret that loved ones may feel following an unexpected suicide.